Your VPN Kill Switch Probably Isn't the One You Think

A VPN kill switch blocks your internet if the tunnel drops, so your real address is never exposed. The part nobody mentions is that most providers ship two versions of it, and the one enabled by default protects you in fewer situations than you think.

What it is meant to do

Proton VPN’s documentation puts the purpose plainly: the feature “stops your real IP address from being exposed to the internet,” and if the connection is lost it “blocks all internet traffic on your device until you’re reconnected.”

That is the whole idea. A VPN tunnel is a piece of software, and software stops — a server goes down, a laptop wakes from sleep on a new network, a phone moves from wifi to cellular. Without a kill switch, your traffic quietly carries on outside the tunnel and nothing tells you.

The two tiers, and why the difference matters

Here is the distinction the one-sentence explanations skip. Proton documents its standard kill switch as being “only activated when your connection drops by accident,” and states that as a result “it doesn’t block your internet connection if you deliberately disconnect.”

Its advanced kill switch, which the same documentation notes is available on Windows, the Linux GUI app and iOS or iPadOS, “only allows internet access when connected to Proton VPN, no exceptions.”

Mullvad splits the same idea across two settings in its app — a kill switch, and a separate lockdown mode — and documents a state where the internet is deliberately blocked because the kill switch is always on.

Two providers, four settings, and the same word doing different work in each. The version most people are running is the permissive one.

What the weaker tier does not cover

If your kill switch only reacts to accidental drops, then it is not protecting you when:

• you disconnect deliberately, intending to reconnect in a moment and then forget
• the app is not running at all, including immediately after a reboot before it starts
• the machine wakes and the network is up before the tunnel is

None of those are exotic. The middle one is how most exposure actually happens: the app is not on, so there is nothing to trigger.

What to check on your own device

Open your VPN’s settings and look for two separate controls rather than one. If there is only a single toggle, find your provider’s documentation and establish which behaviour it describes — the permissive one or the absolute one.

Then test it the only way that proves anything: connect, disconnect deliberately, and see whether your browser still loads a page. If it does, you are running the permissive tier.

One thing a kill switch is not

It is not protection against the tunnel being weak, misconfigured or leaking DNS. It is a single, narrow guarantee — no traffic outside the tunnel — and it says nothing about what happens inside it.